Convictions being tossed for three of the six accused insurrectionists from Macomb County
Federal prosecutors this week took steps to dismiss criminal convictions against three of the six Macomb County residents who took part in the Jan. 6, 2021 insurrection and caused nearly $3 million in damage to the U.S. Capitol.
On the first day following the inauguration, President Donald Trump signed documents pardoning nearly 1,500 supporters suspected of storming the Capitol, referring to the defendants as “hostages.”
“This proclamation ends a grave national injustice that has been perpetrated upon the American people over the last four years and begins a process of national reconciliation,” Trump’s executive order said.
The order grants “a full, complete and unconditional pardon to all other individuals convicted of offenses” and ordered the dismissal of pending indictments. Anyone currently in custody of the Bureau of Prisons was to be released immediately.
According to U.S. Attorney’s Office data and other media reports, the Macomb suspects received sentences ranging from home confinement to two weeks in prison.
Court records show federal prosecutors on Tuesday filed motions to dismiss the indictments of Daniel Herendeen of Chesterfield Township, Robert Schornak, Roseville, and Tim Boughner of Romeo.
Herendeen, 46, and Schornak, 42, described by the FBI as friends, were both charged with obstruction of Congress, aiding and abetting, knowingly entering a restricted area, and disorderly conduct. Both pleaded guilty to entering a restricted building.
A judge ordered Herendeen to serve 14 days in prison, 60 days home detention, three years probation, and to pay $500 in restitution toward repairing damage to the Capitol building, court documents show. Schornak was sentenced to 28 days “intermittent confinement,” two months home detention, three years probation, and $500 restitution.
Herendeen was previously convicted of domestic assault, disorderly conduct and operating while impaired twice between 1995 and 2013. Schornak was convicted of disorderly conduct in 2003 and operating while intoxicated in 2001.
Both men have already served their sentences. Although a pardon nullifies the conviction and eliminates any impact on rights, such as employment, serving on a jury or voting, a commutation doesn’t reverse the conviction; it only reduces the sentence.
On Wednesday, a federal judge dismissed charges against Tim Boughner of Romeo who was accused of engaging in physical violence in a restricted building and other crimes.
U.S. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan said the president’s pardon does not necessarily mean Boughner is innocent. In her ruling, the judge “no pardon can change the tragic truth of what happened” on Jan. 6, 2021.
“The dismissal of this case cannot undo the “rampage (that) left multiple people dead, injured more than 140 people, and inflicted millions of dollars in damage. It cannot diminish the heroism of law enforcement officers who “struggled, facing serious injury and even death, to control the mob that overwhelmed them,” the judge wrote.
“It cannot whitewash the blood, feces, and terror that the mob left in its wake. And it cannot repair the jagged breach in America’s sacred tradition of peacefully transitioning power.”
The government’s video shows Boughner in a crowd at the Capitol and using a chemical spray against officers attempting to secure the building, the government said. He is also accused of using a bike rack to assault officers.
His case had not been adjudicated at the time of Wednesday’s pardon, court records show.
Three other local residents are expected to also have their convictions pardoned.
Earlier this month and before the Inauguration, Mount Clemens businessman Jason Howland was sentenced to serve 36 months of probation, including three months of home detention. He was sentenced Jan. 10 by Judge Trevor N. McFadden of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia.
Howland, 49, a residential bathroom contractor from Clinton Township, pled guilty to civil disorder. FBI agents arrested him in Mount Clemens in January 2024 on five charges, including disorderly conduct and obstruction of an official proceeding, court records show.
In a sentencing memorandum, federal prosecutors asked the judge to send Howland to prison for two years. They said he intended to disrupt Congress from certifying the results of the 2020 presidential election won by President Joseph Biden, called for “war” on Jan. 6 and spent an hour inside the Capitol, longer than other convicted rioters.
“Howland was an avid and willing participant in an unprecedented crime,” Justice Department Trial Attorney Terence Parker wrote in a sentencing memorandum. “He joined a mob that threatened the lives of legislators and their staff, interrupted of the certification of the 2020 Electoral College vote count, injured more than one hundred police officers, and resulted in more than $2.9 million in losses.”
In addition to house arrest, Judge McFadden ordered Howland to pay $10,000 in restitution, fines, and assessments.
His lawyer, Sean Tilton, sought a more lenient sentence, arguing Howland has changed his behavior and noting advisory sentencing guidelines call for no more than a six-month prison sentence.
“He no longer attends protests or rallies,” Tilton wrote. “He has been deterred from engaging in any similar behavior. Mr. Howland has worked very hard to stop using drugs, remain sober, and build and support a family. He regrets putting everything he has worked towards at risk.”
Howland wrote a letter of apology to the judge where took responsibility for his actions on Jan. 6. He said he had a realization after the riot and asked for mercy from the court.
“The realization is that it is not good for me to be involved in events where there is a capacity for the crowd to get out of control,” he wrote. “For a long time I had questioned how seemingly average people got involved things like this. I had seen the stories and asked myself how people could be so foolish. Then, I was there, and it was different. I was the fool.”
Neither Howland nor his attorney responded to requests for comment this week.
Federal prosecutors said the Jan. 6 incident marked the latest criminal offense by Howland.
He has a criminal history that stretches nearly 30 years, including convictions for felony assault with a dangerous weapon, receiving and concealing stolen property and a 2006 guilty plea to ethnic intimidation and attempted assault with a dangerous weapon in St. Clair County.
Howland “repeatedly yelled the N-word at a group of three African American children who were playing at a park,” the prosecutor wrote. “When confronted by the children’s mother, Howland picked up a shovel, threatening to hit her with it and calling her the same racial slur.”
In that case, Howland was sentenced to probation but was sentenced to one year in prison after violating the terms of his probation.
According to The Detroit News, Howland co-founded the American Patriot Council, a group that organized protests in Michigan against Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and other topics. In doing so, he worked with Ryan Kelley, a one-time gubernatorial candidate and real estate broker who was sentenced to 60 days in prison for committing a federal crime during the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. He also is in the process of having his conviction dismissed.
Also expected to have his conviction overturned is James Mels.
Mels, 58, of Shelby Township received a sentence of three years probation, three months home detention, 60 hours community service, and $500 in restitution. He was charged with entering a restricted building, disorderly conduct, disorderly conduct in a Capitol building, and picketing inside the Capitol.
He pleaded guilty to entering a restricted building, according to court records.
Finally, Steven Thurlow, 52, of St. Clair Shores has been sentenced to two years probation, 80 hours community service, and $500 restitution
Thurlow was charged with entering a restricted building, demonstrating in the Capitol and two disorderly conduct charges.
A veteran of the U.S. Army, Thurlow wore bulletproof armor during the insurrection as a mob assaulted police and pushed their way inside the Capitol, according to investigators. Prosecutors said he openly bragged about the group’s involvement on Facebook, giving law enforcement officers evidence that led to his arrest.
Roseville judge denies bond reduction for man accused of lying about missing ex-girlfriend
Everything Trump did in the first executive orders and actions of his presidency
Episcopal bishop says she’ll continue to pray for Trump, who lashed out at her over viral sermon