CDC advisory panel votes to recommend dropping thimerosal from flu vaccines
In todays Health Alert, a major change in flu vaccine guidance. The new CDC advisory panel is recommending that most Americans avoid shots containing a mercury-based preservative.
The panel voted to drop thimerosal from flu vaccines.
This is a big shift, even though it affects a small portion of flu shots. Thimerosal is a mercury-based preservative used in multi-dose vials to prevent contamination. Its been used safely for decades and is found in less than 5% of flu vaccines in the U.S.
Now, when thimerosal enters the body, it breaks down into ethylmercury. Ethylmercury leaves the body fairly quickly and hasnt been linked to serious health issues. Its very different from methylmercury, which is the kind found in fish. Methylmercury is a known neurotoxin and is harmful in high doses.
Despite this, fears about mercury and autism started to spread. Then, in 2001, thimerosal was removed from vaccines used for American children aged 6 years and younger. This happened not because it was proven dangerous, but as a precaution. Over the years, dozens of studies have shown that thimerosal does not cause autism. Still, some anti-vaccine groups continue to spread that misinformation.
The new vaccine panel says even the fear of thimerosal might keep people from getting a flu shot, so they want to recommend thimerosal-free vaccines only.
The panel is recommending only thimerosal-free options - that means single-dose shots and the nasal spray FluMist. It would rule out the multi-dose vials that contain thimerosal, even though theres no solid evidence theyre harmful. Theres concern that removing thimerosal might send the wrong message - like it was dangerous all along, when its not. And it could also make it harder for some clinics to offer the vaccine, since multi-dose vials are cheaper and easier to store.
As for the risk of flu, yes, it is much greater than any risk from thimerosal. The flu can lead to serious complications, hospitalizations, and even death, especially in kids, older adults, and people with weakened immune systems. Just last flu season, we saw 250 pediatric deaths, one of the deadliest years for kids in over a decade.
The good news is, the panel still recommends that nearly everyone 6 months and older get a flu shot each year. Thats because the flu vaccine saves lives. And the protection it gives far outweighs any fear that isnt supported by science.
This Week on the Dr. Nandi Show