Amid controversy, Oakland County's leadership team posts financial disclosures
After months of controversy about county officials having outside jobs on top of their taxpayer-funded positions, Oakland County Executive David Coulter and his leadership team have posted their financial information publicly.
Watch Heather Catallo's video report: Amid controversy, Oakland County's leadership team posts financial disclosures View the disclosures hereLast month, the 7 Investigators showed you how Deputy County Executive Sean Carlson owns Procurement Consulting Group LLC.
Related Story: Advantage or conflict? Oakland Co. senior leader's private business in question Advantage or conflict? Oakland Co. senior leaders private business in questionIts a private company that has provided purchasing staff to local governments, including Livingston County, the Washtenaw Intermediate School District and with neighboring Wayne County.
Carlson was hired by Oakland County in 2019 and taxpayers pay his $224,487 salary.
Records obtained by the 7 Investigators show Carlsons Procurement Consulting Group, or PCG, has been providing Wayne County with procurement staff since 2016. In 2023, PCG landed a Wayne County contract valued at up to $8,467,961.24 for 3 years and can be extended for 7 years for up to $14,522,783.14.
In PCGs Wayne County contract, Carlson is listed as both a principal of the company and the owner.
PCG has also had a contract with the city of Pontiac, where Coulters administration is spending $370 million dollars to move their headquarters. Pontiac city invoices show the city paid Carlsons company $355,780. Carlson told the 7 Investigators he did not know PCG had pursued the Pontiac business until after it was awarded.
Coulter and Carlson have maintained Carlsons outside employment is not a conflict of interest.
Now, a county website lists the outside employment and income for Oakland Countys other deputy county executives and the county's Chief Financial Officer.
Related Story: 'Oakland County is better than this.' Coulter unveils sweeping ethics reforms after 7 Investigation 'Oakland County is better than this.' Coulter unveils sweeping ethics reforms after 7 InvestigationThe 7 Investigators have also shown you how Oakland County Board of Commissioners Chair David Woodward owns two outside companies: Woodward & Associates and Pivot Point Strategies, a political consulting firm. Woodward has admitted hes a paid consultant for the Sheetz gas station chain but will not say how much he earns from them on top of his $82,500 county salary. In past interviews, Woodward would not reveal his other consulting clients but maintains he does not have a conflict of interest.
In December, the Board of Commissioners said Coulters corporation counsel attorneys told them they had no legal authority to require financial disclosure, so the board only passed a resolution to ask the Michigan legislature to enact a law that establishes a uniform statewide financial disclosure framework they can later adopt.
Coulter originally called on the commissioners to adopt financial disclosure statements similar to those adopted by state lawmakers in 2023. But Coulter said he wanted the transparency requirements to go further by extending the rules to the spouses/domestic partners of Oakland County elected officials and Coulters appointees.
Today, his leadership team revealed the names of any outside employment and where they hold properties and investments. Specific income levels or dollar amounts were not made public.
Transparency is essential to maintain the publics confidence in how their government operates, Coulter said. While there is not yet state law requiring such financial disclosure for elected officials, I believe we should lead by example. Thats why my senior leadership team and I are making these disclosures available to the public.
We live in a representative democracy. And so for that to work, people have to trust that their representatives are really working for them, said Jim Townsend, Director of the Carl Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy at Wayne State University Law School. If you want to keep faith with the people you represent, you have to assure them that they can trust you, that you are not being influenced by pay or consulting fees.
Thursdays disclosures revealed another Deputy County Executives outside work. A county spokesman says April Lynch earns more than $244,000 [$224,487.12] a year for her role overseeing the countys human resources and facilities management. Facilities management is currently under scrutiny for the recent Legionella outbreak in county buildings.
Lynch listed a company called RA Holdings in her financial disclosure. What she did not spell out specifically is that RA Holdings biggest client is a company called Double Haul Solutions that helps with recruiting for other municipalities. Video shows Lynch at a City of Saline City Council meeting on March 3, 2025, pitching Double Haul Solutions to help the city find a new city manager. The cost for Lynchs services referenced by Saline city leaders in the meeting was $15,495, plus executive coaching for $3,995.
WEB EXTRA: Deputy Oakland County Exec April Lynch appears before Saline City Council WEB EXTRA: Deputy Oakland County Exec April Lynch appears before Saline City CouncilShe runs HR [for the county], she runs facilities she runs a bunch of stuff and has several hundred employees so where would she find the time? asked Oakland County Commissioner Charlie Cavell about Lynchs outside job.Then if there's Legionella found, then it totally makes sense that someone's attention and focus was distracted elsewhere.
Cavell and Commissioner Kristen Nelson (D-Waterford) have been pushing for ethics reforms since May.
I feel lied to and betrayed. Again, how are people supposed to trust you? asked Cavell. So there are thousands of people that are trusting you're doing your best for the people of Oakland County. So one, they deserve transparency and accountability. But two, if you don't give them that, and then you find out that you might have been busy with some side hustle? Unacceptable!
The 7 Investigators asked Oakland Countys Public Information Officer Bill Mullan whether April Lynchs government consulting work was a conflict of interest. He released this statement to us:
April notified County Executive Coulter about the executive consulting work she does on her own time. He was aware and completely comfortable with it.
Mullan also said Lynch does not do any consulting for municipalities in Oakland County.
Nate Geinzer owns Double Haul Solutions. Geinzer told the 7 Investigators that he is the sole owner and that DHS has not performed any work for Oakland County.
"April has been a trusted colleague of mine for well over 15 years, is deeply respected by her peers, and has been someone who has helped me grow as a professional over the years. Moreover, among her subject matter expertise, she is particularly well versed in municipal human resources management and talent development," said Geinzer. "On a limited, as-needed basis, she engages as a subcontractor to provide executive coaching and human resources advisory services for DHS clients when her availability allows. She does not hold an ownership stake in the company. April's partnership is as a colleague, a thought partner, a coach, a mentor, and a friend."
Meanwhile, in December, the Board of Commissioners decided not to require financial disclosures, alleging the law doesnt allow them to do that.
Cavell says he believes they do have the authority to require disclosure among commissioners, and says he plans to release his own financial information regardless of what the rest of the commission does.
The Oakland County Board of Commissioners can create board policy that is just required for the board to follow and we've done that with all sorts of things, and we can do that for this.It just takes the chairman putting it on an agenda and having us vote for it and [Woodward] has not done that, and he knows he can do that. So that's the real answer, said Cavell.
If you have a story for Heather Catallo, please email her at hcatallo@wxyz.com
