Eisenhower doubles up Rochester United in battle of top 10 teams
ROCHESTER – Nathan Schilkey believes playing Utica Eisenhower in hockey is like picking your poison.
The Eagles have pure goal scorers galore and it’s hard to just defensively key in on one.
On Saturday night, it was Schilkey’s turn to shine, as the senior forward netted the natural hat trick and the Eagles played well defensively in recording a 4-2 triumph over host Rochester United in a battle of top 10 teams at Suburban Ice Rochester.
Eisenhower is ranked seventh in Division 1 and Rochester United is ranked fifth in Division 2.
“It’s tough that we had to (forfeit) those first five games, but we still have a lot of goals for this season,” said Schilkey, who did not play high school hockey last season. “Myself and Joey Zelenak played (AAA hockey) last season but we’ve known all of the Eisenhower guys since we were little and we decided to play with them this year as seniors. We feel like we have a very good team and a lot of guys who can put the puck into the back of the net.”
Eisenhower has not technically lost out on the ice. The Eagles (3-5-0) had their first five games – all convincing wins – stripped away due to the usage of two ineligible players on a not-so-well-known MHSAA rule.
Eisenhower has simply regrouped with three straight wins and this was the first victory over a fellow state-ranked opponent this season.
“What a great high school hockey game,” beamed Eisenhower coach David Erwin. “I mean a very large crown, the atmosphere, the band, and two very talented hockey teams. Rochester United can play. They came at us and gave us a great battle. In terms of competition, I think they are the best team we’ve played this season and we knew going in that they would be tough. They are the top team in (the Oakland Activities Association).
“I can honestly say that our boys have moved on (from the forfeits),” continued Erwin. “We have come back and won (three) straight hockey games and nothing has changed in terms of our goals. We know we haven’t lost on the ice. We still want to go 27-0 and be playing down in Plymouth (for the D-1 Final Four and USA Hockey Arena). That’s our goal. We are a little thinner right now with injuries, but we still are having guys stepping up and doing a great job.”
Eisenhower (3-5-0) never trailed and took a 1-0 lead with 10:44 left in the first period. Schilkey was left open near the net and sent the puck home following a feed from Sebastian Kolodziej.
Rochester United (10-2-0) netted an equalizer early in the second period when Nolan Hizer scored his 11th goal of the season off a breakaway pass from Dylan Turnbull with 14:31 still remaining in the frame.
Just over seven minutes later, Schilkey blasted in a wrist shot from distance off the power play with 7:07 left in the period, set up by Zelanak and Bode Farr.
The close affair saw Rochester United again tie it up with just 42 ticks remaining in the second when Zach Brennan scored his ninth of the campaign to make it 2-2. Nolan Hiser (20 assists) and Mason McCaughtry had the helpers on the game-tying goal.
Rochester United let its guard down and Eisenhower made the hosts pay.
Schilkey scored his third goal of the evening while being left alone in front of the net and tucking in the game-winner with only seven seconds remaining in the second period off feeds from Zelenak and Farr.
Eisenhower played tight defense throughout and eventually scored an insurance goal with 4:38 left in the contest. Ryan Dex made it 4-2 after picking up a steal and sending home his shot past Rochester United goaltender Levi Joler.
The Eagles picked up another strong outing from senior goaltender Connor Holmes, who recorded 29 saves in 31 chances for Eisenhower. Joler had 36 stops in 40 chances for Rochester United, which has still scored 54 goals offensively this season while conceding 29 goals.

“This was a great game, we just came up a little bit short,” admitted Rochester United assistant coach Zach Lietz, who filled in the press conference for head coach Tucker Penning. “We knew Eisenhower has three really good (goal scorers) and a very good goalie. They are a tough team, and we feel like we also have a very good team. It was a close game and knew it would be.
“I thought the atmosphere was great, and this is the type of game that we want to play in, win or lose,” continued Lietz. “It was a top 10 matchup and something that we prepared for and this was a great test for them tonight. Obviously, only one team can win and unfortunately it went their way tonight. But I thought both teams played well .Now, we are just looking forward to next week and try to get back to (winning) games.”
The loss was Rochester United’s second defeat and first against a Michigan team this season. United also lost to Toledo (Ohio) St. Francis de Sales last month and that team is ranked in the top five in Ohio rankings.


