Tigers’ Tarik Skubal clarifies logic behind exit after 6 innings in Game 5 of ALDS
DETROIT — The issue came up again during Tarik Skubal’s post-Cy Young Award media teleconference Wednesday night.
Not that issue.
Of course, he was asked about his future with the Tigers and he said what he has said all along: He loves being a Tiger. He hopes he can be a Tiger for a long time. But the ultimate decision is largely out of his control.
But that’s not the issue we’re talking about here.
If there is one loose thread that still needs to be secured from the 2025 season, one topic that keeps coming up in media and fan debates, it’s manager AJ Hinch’s decision to pull Skubal after the sixth inning of the season-ending, 15-inning loss in Seattle in Game 5 of the American League Division Series.To review:
The Tigers took a 2-1 lead into the bottom of the sixth on Kerry Carpenter’s clutch, left-on-left homer off reliever Gabe Speier. And Skubal was cruising. He set down 14 straight Mariners hitters from the second through the sixth, punching out 10 of them including seven in a row in one stretch.
In the sixth, as his pitch count pushed toward 100, he struck out J.P. Crawford with a 99.7-mph heater and finished the inning with a three-pitch punch-out of Cal Raleigh — 99.7, 99.1 and 100.9 mph on his 99th and final pitch.
But the seeds for the decision to pull him at that point were planted an inning earlier, as Hinch explained after the game.
“Easy decision,” Hinch said. “After the fifth, I checked in on him how he was doing physically and emotionally, and we both knew that he had one (inning) left. You know, he emptied his tank and obviously was emotional coming off the mound, and I think that signals exactly where we were in the game.
“He gave us everything he could.”
The Mariners tied the game in the bottom of the seventh against relievers Kyle Finnegan and Tyler Holton and ultimately won it on a walk-off single by Jorge Polanco in the 15th inning.
By that time, Skubal had been out of the game for nine innings. And by the time he addressed the media post-game, the sixth-inning decision was buried beneath the rubble of the heartbreaking ending.
Wednesday night was the first time he talked in depth about that decision and, as usual, he provided some much-needed insight and clarity.
“That was the decision that was made and me and AJ are always on the same page,” he said. “I really respect everything that he does. He’s got a plan for everything. Trust me, I’ve seen a lot of the stuff about how the fans were disappointed or whatever. But it’s just the way the game of baseball is.”
Skubal took the mound in the sixth inning knowing it was going to be his last. And accordingly, he went full-throttle. The 100.9-mph fastball that he blew by Raleigh was pitch 99 of the game and career-high pitch 3,152 of the season.
It came in his career-high 216th inning.
While it may look like you’re watching a video game when Skubal is dominating like that, he’s still a human being. And, as he intimated, he was pitching through some aches and pains.
“The season will run you down a little bit,” he said Wednesday.
But there was a baseball strategy component to the decision that trumped whatever fatigue issues Skubal might’ve been dealing with. Due up for the Mariners in the bottom of the seventh inning that night were right-handed hitters Julio Rodriguez, Polanco and Eugenio Suarez.
Polanco’s presence probably sealed the decision. You might remember, Polanco homered twice off Skubal in Game 2 and seemed to be seeing his pitches as well as any Mariners hitter.
“The way the at-bats had gone with Polanco, even earlier in that game he hit a foul-ball homer,” Skubal said. “I just don’t think that matchup was going to be in the cards that night.”
As it turned out, Finnegan walked Polanco and gave up a two-out single to Josh Naylor, which set the table for pinch-hitter Leo Rivas’ game-tying single off Holton.
“Look, I’m going to go out and compete and give it everything I have,” Skubal said. “I knew my outing was coming to a close there with Polanco looming. Hindsight is 20-20. If you could write a perfect script, we obviously would go do that. I would love to throw 300 pitches every time out. I just don’t know if that’s realistic. Especially in that setting with the lead and nine outs to go.
“I trust our guys in the bullpen 10 out of 10 times to end a game like that.”
That sixth inning decision is fun to debate. But it was well thought-out, logical and on-brand for how Hinch managed all season. It was mutually agreed upon and hardly fatal. If you are looking to point fingers, scoring in just one of 15 innings, going 1 for 9 with runners in scoring position (0 for 6 in extra innings) and leaving 10 runners on base is more the culprit.
“We played in one of the best win-or-go-home games in baseball history,” Skubal said. “We came out the wrong side of that. But at the same time, I thought everybody competed and left it all out there, including myself. As an athlete, that’s all you really can do.”
No more loose threads.

